The Future of Scholarly Blogs
The Future of Scholarly Blogs
Catharina Ochsner and Heinz Pampel
Scholarly blogs communicate research and research related topics but unlike more formal scientific output, such as conference proceedings, journal articles or monographs, it is not yet common to include blogs into library or archival collections. While blogs are openly accessible through the web and are often viewed to be a more fleeting or informal publication type, they cite and are cited by more formal publication types, which makes them part of the scholarly record. However, the ephemeral nature of blogs also puts them at risk of being lost and leaving a gap in the scholarly record. To close this gap, we talked to 13 scholarly bloggers and asked about their challenges concerning blog preservation and their requirements for a digital infrastructure that could potentially secure scholarly blogs in the long-term. These are our findings:
Participants reported a range of personal challenges they perceived have negatively impacted their engagement with blog preservation. Several participants declared that they did not possess knowledge about long-term preservation, preservation practices, and information infrastructure institutions, such as libraries and archives. Many participants also said that they lack time to engage with the topic. The results further indicate that bloggers face challenges, consisting of a lack of institutional recognition and support, and ambiguity regarding responsibility for long-term preservation.
—The ephemeral nature of blogs also puts them at risk of being lost and leaving a gap in the scholarly record—
Although participants expressed a general desire for their blogs to remain long-term accessible, they articulated differing views on which types of content should be preserved. Some participants regarded all materials as worthy of preservation, as illustrated by one of the participants: “As long as there is enough storage space, I would save everything”. Several participants expressed a desire for bloggers to have agency in determining which materials should be preserved: “If you could control that individually, that wouldn’t be bad. Let the bloggers decide”.
Most participants did not propose concrete technical and organizational requirements and instead articulated broad ideas about what long-term preservation should entail. Key technical and organizational needs included stable persistent identifiers (PIDs), metadata support, interoperability, and transparency regarding the conditions under which content is preserved. PIDs and metadata require coordination across bloggers, platform providers (e.g, Hypotheses, ScienceBlogs, Substack), and infrastructure institutions.
A prominent concern for several participants was the question of governance. Most participants preferred government-funded institutions over commercial options. For example, one participant argued that this responsibility should lie exclusively with government-funded institutions, stating: “For me things like cultural heritage are not tasks of private institutions”. Institutions that participants saw as fit to ensure blog preservation were libraries (especially national and university libraries) and institutional repositories, web archives (the Internet Archive and the blog archive Rogue Scholar) and platform providers.
The requirements articulated by bloggers frame preservation not as a singular but as a distributed task. It is unlikely that any single organization or infrastructure institution can assume sole responsibility for comprehensive preservation efforts. Participants also named different actors to contribute to blog preservation and rejected the notion of a single responsible actor. Findings show that no single stakeholder is perceived as capable of guaranteeing long-term preservation alone. We argue for extending the scope of existing decentralized infrastructure institutions to include preservation efforts for scholarly blogs. Such an infrastructure would distribute responsibility across multiple stakeholders, mitigate risks associated with political volatility, censorship, cyberattacks, and platform instability, and allow for different preservation routes. Building a distributed, interoperable, and community-supported infrastructure would not only secure long-term access to scholarly blogs but also strengthen their visibility, citability, and legitimacy within the broader scholarly communication ecosystem.
While this study contributed to the existing research with novel findings, these findings could be expanded on by future research. Since this study was concerned with bloggers’ requirements for information infrastructures, future research could investigate good-practice solutions in information infrastructure institutions. Moreover, future research can build on this study by proposing a concrete practical implementation of a decentralized information infrastructure tasked with the preservation for scholarly blogs.
Read more:
Ochsner, C., & Pampel, H. (2026). The future of scholarly blogs: Scholarly bloggers’ perspectives on long-term preservation. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 1–17. https://doi.org/10.1002/asi.70126
Cite this article in APA as: Ochsner, C. & Pampel, H. (2026, October 28). The future of scholarly blogs. Information Matters. https://informationmatters.org/2026/10/the-future-of-scholarly-blogs/
Authors
-
View all posts
Research associate at the Berlin School of Library and Information Science at Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin.
-